No Big Deal
My latest column in The Boston Globe explores the alternative to sweeping international agreements: little incremental solutions that might, in fact, do better at addressing the world’s ills.
The great international problems of our time beggar the imagination: global warming, pandemics, war crimes, nuclear proliferation, just to name a few. Their complexity confounds the most agile of technocrats, and the stakes involved are high, affecting billions of people living under every sort of government.
For half a century, the conventional approach to these problems has been to build massive international treaties. Intricate worldwide problems demand an integrated approach — a grand bargain, so to speak, that addresses all the winners and losers in a single, encompassing agreement.
This is the animating assumption behind the world’s approach to global warming, for example. To persuade growing nations like China to limit their consumption of fossil fuels, the thinking goes, the world needs a comprehensive framework ensuring that more developed nations make equivalent sacrifices. The climate is simply too large a problem to address piecemeal, or by tinkering with minor symptoms.
But what if this approach results in less progress? What if more modest agreements — on climate change, loose nukes, and other sweeping problems — would yield better results than a long, noble quest for a grand bargain?
I just had to send you a quick note to tell you how much I enjoyed reading “No Big Deal”. I do hope you get quite a lot of kudos for it as it is a wonderful way to stay engaged with and better the world without being daunted by the magnitude of our many problems. I happen to be involved in this new start up called earthbongo. It is a social networking site for good that aims to make a dent in intractable problems by allow many people to make many small changes. This is how our press release begins:
“We all do small things every day to make our environment a little safer, healthier, greener. But at one time or another, many of us have a moment when we ask ourselves, “The world’s problems are so big; can what little I do make a difference?” As it turns out, yes, it can—especially when lots of people do small things that add up to make a big difference.”
You can see why I appreciated your article!
[…] Cambanis writes in an article “No Big Deal” about what it takes to solve such […]